Netnod responds to Root Server System Governance Structure document
Netnod welcomes the opportunity to provide feedback on the Root Server System Governance Structure document by the ICANN Root Server System Governance Working Group (RSS GWG).
Netnod emphasises the critical importance of accountability and transparency within the governance structure for the DNS root server system. The longevity of this structure is intrinsically linked to its acceptance by the global community, including individuals, states, and corporations.
Netnod believes that control mechanisms related to the Governance Principles should not be deferred to later stages. The constant iteration between principles, models, and implementation is likely to provide a better end outcome, and could avoid potential lock-ins based on early decisions which have not yet been implemented.
As the operator of i-root, one of the 13 logical Internet DNS root name servers, Netnod sees the increasing demands from nation-states and large corporations as a threat to the Internet's current form. We believe that governance structures for the Internet and its functions must be meticulously designed, strictly adhering to the well-established multi-stakeholder model. A guiding principle for this process must be the preservation of a globally unique public name space.
Netnod asserts that global political and corporate actors with significant influence require reassurance through the accountability and transparency provided by the governance structure, even if they are not direct constituents of the Root Server System Governance Structure itself. It must be unequivocally clear to external observers that the DNS root server system functions effectively and possesses robust accountability mechanisms.
Further work is needed to address and rationalise the actual implementations of the governance structure, including its organisational form, jurisdictional considerations, and the constitution and capture of these elements. Netnod welcomes a deeper exploration of how the Governance Principles can be incorporated at later stages of the process.
See the PDF response below for Netnod’s full comments.
